City investing

Tax-Equivalent Yield Calculator for Municipal Bonds

A notebook with handwritten percentages, a simple calculator and a printed tax bracket table on a sunlit desk, a cup of coffee at the edge of the frame. (AI-generated image)AI
AI-generated image

The citizen investor

Tax-equivalent yield calculator: compare a tax-free muni yield with a taxable one, with the formula, the state-tax version and two worked examples.

citizinvestor / Independent city journal

A tax-free yield of 3 percent and a taxable yield of 4 percent cannot be compared directly. One is what the investor keeps; the other is what the investor keeps before the IRS takes a share. This tax-equivalent yield calculator does the conversion: it takes the yield on a tax-exempt municipal bond and a tax rate, and returns the taxable yield that would leave the same amount after tax.

The calculator needs two inputs, the municipal bond's yield and your marginal tax rate. The explanation below shows what it does with them and where its answer stops being exact.

—

The result is the yield a fully taxable bond would need to pay to leave the same income after federal and state tax. It assumes the muni is exempt from both.

01The basic formula

Taxable-equivalent yield = municipal yield ÷ (1 − marginal tax rate)

The marginal rate is the rate on the last dollar of income, not the average rate across all income. Tax-exempt interest is, in effect, the top slice of income that escapes tax, so the top rate is the one that applies.

The formula also runs backwards. To find what a taxable bond leaves after tax, multiply its yield by (1 − marginal tax rate). A taxable yield of 5 percent at a 24 percent marginal rate leaves 5 × 0.76 = 3.80 percent, so a tax-exempt bond paying more than 3.80 percent would come out ahead for that taxpayer.

Both versions answer the same question from opposite ends. The calculator uses the first.

02Adding state income tax

Section 103 of the Internal Revenue Code exempts most municipal bond interest from federal income tax. State tax is separate. Most states with an income tax exempt interest on bonds issued within the state and tax interest on bonds from other states. For an in-state bond that is free of both, the tax rate in the formula becomes a combined rate.

Combined rate, simple version = federal rate + state rate

That simple sum fits most taxpayers. A taxpayer who itemizes and still has room under the federal cap on state and local tax deductions gets a slightly lower combined rate, because each dollar of state tax also trims federal tax:

Combined rate, with state tax deductible = federal rate + state rate × (1 − federal rate)

For an out-of-state municipal bond, the interest is federally exempt but taxed by the home state. Compared with a fully taxable bond, the equivalent yield is then: municipal yield × (1 − state rate) ÷ (1 − federal rate − state rate).

High earners subject to the 3.8 percent net investment income tax can add it to the federal rate, since excluded municipal interest is not part of net investment income while taxable bond interest is.

03Worked example 1: federal tax only

These numbers are hypothetical and chosen only to show the arithmetic.

A single filer in a 24 percent federal bracket is looking at a municipal bond yielding 3.00 percent. She lives in a state with no income tax.

Taxable-equivalent yield = 3.00 ÷ (1 − 0.24) = 3.00 ÷ 0.76 = 3.95 percent.

A taxable bond would need to yield more than about 3.95 percent to leave her more after tax. If a comparable taxable bond of similar quality and maturity yields 3.70 percent, the muni comes out ahead; if it yields 4.20 percent, the taxable bond does.

04Worked example 2: federal and state tax

Again, hypothetical numbers. A married couple sits in a 32 percent federal bracket and pays a flat 5 percent state income tax. They are looking at an in-state municipal bond yielding 3.50 percent, exempt from both.

Using the simple combined rate: 0.32 + 0.05 = 0.37.

Taxable-equivalent yield = 3.50 ÷ (1 − 0.37) = 3.50 ÷ 0.63 = 5.56 percent.

If they could deduct the state tax on their federal return, the combined rate would be 0.32 + 0.05 × 0.68 = 0.354, and the taxable-equivalent yield 3.50 ÷ 0.646 = 5.42 percent. Either way, the state exemption adds well over a full percentage point to the comparison. That gap is why residents of high-tax states often look first at bonds from their own state, and why single-state municipal bond ETFs exist.

05Where the calculator's answer stops being exact

The formula assumes the whole yield is tax-exempt and the whole comparison yield is taxed at the same marginal rate. Real cases bend that in a few places.

The alternative minimum tax. Interest on specified private activity bonds counts toward the AMT. For an AMT payer, part of the "tax-free" yield is taxed.

Bonds bought at a discount. If the discount exceeds the de minimis threshold, the gain at maturity is taxed as ordinary income, so part of the yield is not tax-exempt. The tax-free municipal bonds guide explains the rule.

Social Security. Tax-exempt interest counts toward the provisional income that determines how much of a Social Security benefit is taxed, under IRS Publication 915. For some retirees, a tax-free dollar still raises the tax bill indirectly.

Callable bonds. The yield to plug in should be the yield to worst, not the coupon, as the guide to municipal bond yields explains.

Different risks. The calculator compares yields, not credit quality, liquidity or call features. A tax-exempt bond from a small revenue project and a Treasury bill are not the same risk, even at the same after-tax yield. Treasury interest is also exempt from state tax, so for that comparison only the federal rate applies to the Treasury side.

A last observation, slightly off the arithmetic. The same formula sits behind the borrowing cost of every town that issues tax-exempt debt. Because investors accept lower yields on tax-free bonds, a city building a library or replacing water mains pays less interest than a company would on the same loan. The municipal bonds overview shows where that money goes, and the taxable municipal bonds guide covers the bonds for which the comparison runs the other way.

FAQ

What is the formula for tax-equivalent yield?

Divide the tax-free yield by one minus the marginal tax rate. A municipal bond yielding 3 percent for someone in a 24 percent bracket has a tax-equivalent yield of 3 ÷ 0.76, about 3.95 percent. To include state tax on an in-state bond, use a combined federal and state rate in place of the federal rate alone.

Should I use my marginal or my effective tax rate?

The marginal rate. Tax-exempt interest replaces income that would otherwise be taxed at the rate on the last dollars earned, which is the marginal rate. Using the lower effective, or average, rate would understate the value of the exemption. If a bond's interest could push income into a higher bracket, the higher rate is the relevant one.

How does state income tax change the tax-equivalent yield?

For an in-state bond exempt from both federal and state tax, the combined rate is higher, so the tax-equivalent yield rises. In the hypothetical example on this page, adding a 5 percent state tax to a 32 percent federal rate lifts the equivalent of a 3.50 percent muni yield from about 5.15 to about 5.56 percent.

At what tax bracket do municipal bonds make sense?

There is no fixed bracket. The break-even depends on the gap between tax-free and taxable yields at the time, which moves constantly. Divide the muni yield by a comparable taxable yield and subtract the result from one: the answer is the marginal rate at which the two are equal. Above it, the muni yields more after tax.

Does the calculator account for the alternative minimum tax?

No. It assumes the full municipal yield is free of federal income tax. Interest on specified private activity bonds is subject to the AMT, so for taxpayers who owe it, part of that interest is taxed and the true tax-equivalent yield is lower. The bond's official statement or the dealer's description says whether it is an AMT bond.