When Central Falls, Rhode Island, filed for Chapter 9 bankruptcy on August 1, 2011, two groups of people were owed money by the same small city. One group held its general obligation bonds. The other was made up of retired police officers and firefighters. By the time the city came out of bankruptcy in 2012, the bondholders had been paid every scheduled dollar, on time, thanks to a state law passed weeks before the filing that gave them a first lien on property taxes. Some of the retirees had seen their pensions cut by as much as 55 percent.
That case is often quoted as proof that municipal bonds are safe. It proves something narrower. Whether municipal bonds are a good investment depends on who is holding them, which bonds they are, and what the holder needs the money to do.
01What municipal bonds do well
Three features draw most buyers.
The first is the tax treatment. Interest on most munis is excluded from federal income tax under Section 103 of the Internal Revenue Code, and many states exempt interest on their own bonds. For someone in a high bracket, a lower tax-free yield can be worth more than a higher taxable one. The tax-free municipal bonds guide sets out the exceptions.
The second is predictable income. A typical bond pays interest twice a year on fixed dates and returns its face value at maturity. For people living on their savings, that schedule is the point. It sits alongside the other income options retirees weigh, such as the multi-asset funds, property funds and dividend funds described in three ways to rethink monthly income investments for retirement.
The third is a long record of low defaults. Rating agencies' municipal default studies have consistently found that rated municipal bonds default far less often than corporate bonds with the same rating. Cities rarely disappear, and they can raise taxes or fees in a way a struggling company cannot.
02Credit risk is low, not zero
Low is not the same as none. Detroit's 2013 bankruptcy, the largest municipal filing in U.S. history, ended with some of its bondholders accepting less than they were owed. Puerto Rico, which as a territory cannot use Chapter 9, went through years of debt restructuring under PROMESA, the oversight law Congress passed in 2016. Smaller defaults cluster in revenue bonds for single projects, such as a nursing home or a toll road whose traffic never came.
The SEC's investor bulletin on municipal credit risk makes a point worth repeating: a credit rating is an opinion at a point in time, and the rating printed in an official statement may no longer be the rating when someone buys the bond years later. The issuer's annual filings on EMMA are the place to check what has changed.
Central Falls also shows where the pain of a municipal default lands. The bankruptcy left the city short of staff and money for public works. Afterwards, residents pledged online for steel trash and recycling bins in Jenks Park, the city's main green space, as described on the Jenks Park bins page. That is a cost no bond rating measures.
03Interest rate risk
Bond prices move opposite to interest rates. If rates rise after a purchase, the bond's market price falls, because new bonds now pay more. A holder who keeps the bond to maturity still gets the face value back. A holder who must sell early may take a loss. The longer the maturity, the larger the swing. The guide to how municipal bond yields work explains the arithmetic.
04Call risk and reinvestment risk
Many municipal bonds are callable, meaning the issuer can repay them early on set dates, often at par. Issuers tend to call bonds when rates have fallen and they can borrow more cheaply. The holder gets the principal back sooner than planned, just when new bonds pay less. Call dates and prices are fixed in the official statement, so they are known before purchase.
05Liquidity risk
Most individual municipal bonds trade rarely. Thousands of issuers each sell many small maturities, and a given CUSIP may go weeks without a trade. Selling a $10,000 position in a small school district's bond can mean accepting a lower price than the screen suggests. The MSRB adds that bonds trading at a deep discount can be especially hard to sell, because many buyers avoid the tax treatment of large discounts.
One quirk: this illiquidity is partly why funds exist. A municipal bond fund can be sold any business day, even when the bonds inside it barely trade, which is convenient for the seller and occasionally awkward for the fund.
06Inflation and tax-law risk
A fixed coupon buys less as prices rise, and a 20-year bond carries that exposure for two decades. Tax law can change too. The exemption has survived a long time, but Congress has narrowed it before, most recently by ending tax-exempt advance refundings after 2017. A change in tax rates also changes how much the exemption is worth.
07Who they tend to suit, and who not
On the arithmetic alone, tax-exempt municipal bonds tend to make most sense for investors in higher federal brackets, especially those buying bonds issued in their own high-tax state, who want steady income and expect to hold to maturity. The tax-equivalent yield calculator shows where the break-even bracket falls for any pair of yields.
They tend to make less sense for investors in low brackets, for money inside an IRA or 401(k), where the exemption is wasted, and for savings that need to grow faster than inflation over long periods. None of this is a recommendation for any particular bond or fund. The question is about fit, and a tax adviser or financial professional can test it against an individual return.
FAQ
Are municipal bonds safe?
They have a long record of low default rates compared with corporate bonds of similar ratings, but they are not risk-free. Central Falls, Detroit and Puerto Rico all failed to pay or restructured debt. Prices also fall when interest rates rise, and some bonds are hard to sell quickly. Reading the official statement and recent filings on EMMA is the basic check.
Who should consider municipal bonds?
On the numbers, they tend to fit investors in higher federal tax brackets who want regular income and expect to hold bonds to maturity, particularly residents of high-tax states buying in-state bonds. Investors in low brackets often get more after tax from taxable bonds. Money held in tax-deferred retirement accounts gains nothing from the exemption.
Can you lose money on municipal bonds?
Yes. An issuer can default or restructure, as in Detroit and Puerto Rico. A bond sold before maturity can fetch less than its purchase price if rates have risen. A bond bought above par and called early can return less than was paid. Bond funds have no maturity date, so their share price can stay below the purchase price.
Are municipal bonds better than CDs or Treasury bonds?
They are different, not better. Bank CDs carry FDIC insurance up to the legal limit, and Treasury interest is exempt from state tax but not federal tax. Municipal interest is usually exempt from federal tax and sometimes state tax, but munis carry credit and liquidity risk. Comparing after-tax yields for one's own bracket is the fair test.
What happens to bondholders if a city goes bankrupt?
It depends on the bond and the state. In Central Falls, a 2011 state law gave general obligation bondholders a first lien on property taxes, and they were paid in full. In Detroit, some bondholders accepted losses. Revenue bondholders are usually repaid from the pledged revenue stream, which can keep flowing even during a city bankruptcy.
