A municipal bond's trade confirmation shows two numbers that look as if they should match and usually do not: the coupon and the yield. A bond with a 4 percent coupon can be bought at a yield of 3.5 percent, or 4.5 percent, depending on the day and the price. Anyone looking up municipal bond rates is really asking about the second number. This page explains where it comes from. It does not quote any live rates, because those change every trading day; the free source for them is the MSRB's EMMA website.
01Coupon, price and yield
The coupon is fixed when the bond is issued. A $5,000 bond with a 4 percent coupon pays $200 a year, usually in two $100 payments, for its whole life.
The price is what the bond trades for today, quoted as a percentage of face value. A price of 100 is par, so $5,000 for a $5,000 bond. A price of 102 means paying $5,100; a price of 97.5 means paying $4,875. The MSRB's pricing guides use the same convention.
The yield ties the two together. It is the annual return the buyer earns given the price paid, the coupons received and the amount returned at the end. When a bond's price goes up, its yield goes down, and the reverse.
Why do prices change at all? Because new bonds keep being issued at whatever rates the market sets that week. If new bonds of similar quality pay 5 percent, nobody will pay par for an old 4 percent bond. Its price falls until its yield roughly matches. If new bonds pay 3 percent, the old 4 percent bond becomes more valuable and its price rises above par. That inverse link between rates and prices is what the MSRB and the SEC call interest rate risk.
02Four ways to measure yield
Current yield is the simplest: annual coupon divided by price. The hypothetical bond above, bought at 102, has a current yield of $200 / $5,100, or about 3.92 percent. It ignores the fact that the buyer paid $5,100 and will get back only $5,000.
Yield to maturity accounts for that. It is the single rate that makes the present value of all remaining coupons plus the final principal equal the price paid. For the same hypothetical bond with 15 years left, it comes to roughly 3.82 percent. The extra $100 paid up front is spread across those years as a small loss.
Yield to call applies to callable bonds. Many municipal bonds let the issuer repay them early, often at par after about ten years. If the hypothetical bond can be called at par in five years, the buyer would receive five years of coupons and then $5,000 back. Measured that way, the yield is about 3.56 percent.
Yield to worst is the lowest of the yield to maturity and the yields to each possible call date. MSRB Rule G-15 requires dealers to show, on customer confirmations, a yield computed to the call or maturity date that produces the lower number. For a premium bond like this one, that is usually the call date. For a bond bought below par, the call is unlikely to hurt the buyer, and yield to maturity is usually the worst case.
03Why so many munis trade above par
For years, a common structure in the municipal market has been a bond with a relatively high coupon, often 5 percent, callable at par after about ten years. Such bonds are frequently sold above par from day one. Buyers accept the premium in exchange for higher cash income, and issuers keep the option to refinance if rates fall.
The flip side shows up when rates rise. Bonds that drift below par can fall outside the IRS de minimis threshold, which turns part of the eventual gain into ordinary income. The MSRB has warned that such deep-discount bonds can also be harder to sell. The tax-free municipal bonds guide explains the de minimis rule.
04What moves municipal bond rates
The general level of interest rates. Municipal yields move broadly with Treasury yields and with expectations about Federal Reserve policy, though not one for one.
Maturity. Longer bonds usually yield more than shorter ones, producing an upward-sloping yield curve. Market data providers publish benchmark curves for top-rated (AAA) municipal debt, and EMMA displays yield curves alongside its trade data.
Credit. A bond from a city with weak finances, or a revenue bond for a single project, must pay more than a top-rated general obligation bond. The difference is called the credit spread. When Central Falls, Rhode Island, entered Chapter 9 in 2011, a state law kept its general obligation bondholders paid while city projects went unfunded; residents later pledged online for new bins in its main park, as told on the Jenks Park project page. The municipal bonds overview has the rest of the case.
Supply and demand. Heavy new issuance can push yields up; strong inflows into municipal funds can push them down. Demand from in-state residents can make bonds from high-tax states yield a little less.
Taxes. Because the value of a tax exemption rises with tax rates, changes in federal rates, or expectations of them, can shift municipal yields relative to taxable ones. Market participants track the ratio of AAA municipal yields to Treasury yields as a rough gauge of how expensive munis are.
Liquidity and size. Small, rarely traded issues often trade at higher yields than large, frequently traded ones from well-known issuers.
05Reading yields on EMMA
Every trade reported to the MSRB, generally within 15 minutes, shows up on EMMA with its price and yield. A single bond's trade history often reveals a pattern: dealers buying from customers at one level and selling to customers at a slightly higher price (lower yield). That spread is the dealer's markup and markdown. The how to buy municipal bonds guide covers it.
A short tangent: EMMA's trade data goes back to January 2005, when the MSRB's Real-Time Transaction Reporting System began, so the price history of an older bond can be followed trade by trade from that point on.
To compare a tax-exempt yield with a taxable one, such as a corporate bond or a CD, the yield has to be adjusted for taxes first. The tax-equivalent yield calculator does that.
FAQ
What is the difference between a bond's coupon and its yield?
The coupon is the fixed interest rate printed on the bond, applied to its face value. The yield is the return a buyer earns given the price paid. If the bond is bought above par, the yield is lower than the coupon; if bought below par, it is higher. Only a bond bought exactly at par has a yield equal to its coupon.
Why do municipal bond prices fall when interest rates rise?
Because newly issued bonds start paying the higher rates. An older bond with a lower fixed coupon is less attractive, so its price drops until its yield is competitive with new bonds of similar quality and maturity. The longer the time to maturity, the larger the price change for a given move in rates.
What is yield to worst on a municipal bond?
It is the lowest yield a buyer could receive, calculated across the maturity date and each date on which the issuer may call the bond. MSRB Rule G-15 requires dealer confirmations to show the yield to the call or maturity date that produces the lower figure. For bonds bought above par, the worst case is usually an early call.
Where can I find current municipal bond rates?
The MSRB's free EMMA website shows prices and yields for reported trades, generally within 15 minutes of the trade, plus yield curves and market statistics. Brokerage firms show offering yields for bonds they have in inventory. This site does not publish live rates, because they change every trading day.
Why are municipal bond yields lower than corporate bond yields?
Mostly because the interest on most municipal bonds is exempt from federal income tax, so investors accept a lower stated yield. Municipal issuers also have a long record of low default rates. Comparing the two fairly requires a tax-equivalent yield, which converts a tax-free yield into the taxable yield it matches for a given bracket.
