City investing

Taxable Municipal Bonds and Why Cities Issue Them

Workers in hard hats installing steel beams on a new public transit station platform under a bright sky, a city skyline in the distance. (AI-generated image)AI
AI-generated image

The citizen investor

Taxable municipal bonds explained: why cities sell them, what Build America Bonds were, how state tax applies and which investors tend to hold them.

citizinvestor / Independent city journal

Between April 2009 and the end of 2010, American states and cities sold more than $181 billion of a kind of bond that paid fully taxable interest, in 2,275 separate issues, according to Treasury and IRS figures. They were Build America Bonds, created by the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, and for those two years they made taxable municipal bonds a large slice of new municipal borrowing.

The program ended. Taxable munis did not.

01What makes a municipal bond taxable

A taxable municipal bond is issued by the same kinds of bodies as any other muni: states, cities, counties, school districts, public authorities. It is backed by the same pledges, a general obligation promise or a specific revenue stream. The only difference is that the interest is included in the holder's federal gross income.

That happens when a bond falls outside the exemption in Section 103 of the Internal Revenue Code. Section 103 excludes private activity bonds that are not "qualified," arbitrage bonds, and bonds that fail the registration rules in Section 149. Some deals land outside those lines by necessity. Others are taxable by choice, because a subsidy or the shape of the market makes taxable borrowing cheaper.

02Why issuers sell them

The project has too much private use. Federal rules limit how much of a tax-exempt bond's proceeds can benefit private businesses. A city financing a facility that a private company will largely use, or an economic development loan to a company, may have to borrow on a taxable basis.

The proceeds would be invested, not spent. A city that borrows at a low tax-exempt rate to invest in higher-yielding securities would be creating an arbitrage bond. That is why pension obligation bonds, which governments issue to put borrowed money into their pension funds, are taxable.

Refinancing early. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act ended tax-exempt advance refunding bonds issued after December 31, 2017. An issuer that wants to refinance more than 90 days before the old bonds can be called now often uses taxable bonds to do it.

A federal subsidy. Build America Bonds were the clearest example. Instead of giving investors a tax exemption, the Treasury paid issuers a direct subsidy equal to 35 percent of the interest on most BABs (45 percent for Recovery Zone Economic Development Bonds, which were capped at $10 billion nationwide). The taxable bonds paid higher rates, but after the subsidy the issuer's net cost was often lower than on tax-exempt debt, and the bonds reached buyers who never touch tax-exempt munis.

A wider pool of buyers. Pension funds, foreign investors and holders of tax-deferred accounts gain nothing from a tax exemption. Selling taxable bonds lets an issuer reach them, which sometimes produces a lower all-in cost on large deals.

03What became of Build America Bonds

BABs could be issued only from early 2009 through December 31, 2010. Many of them were long-term bonds, so plenty are still outstanding. The Federal Highway Administration reported that about $48 billion of BAB issuance went to surface transportation; the rest paid for schools, water systems, transit and public buildings.

The subsidy did not stay whole. Since 2013, federal budget sequestration has reduced the payments to issuers each year. Many BAB indentures allow the issuer to redeem the bonds early if the subsidy is cut, and some issuers have used that clause to refinance, which has led to disputes with bondholders over the redemption price. Proposals to revive a BAB-style program have appeared in Congress several times since 2010.

04How they are taxed

Interest on a taxable municipal bond is subject to federal income tax at ordinary rates, like interest on a corporate bond. State tax is a separate matter. Some states exempt interest on their own issuers' bonds whether or not the bonds are federally taxable, so a resident buying an in-state taxable muni may still avoid state income tax. Others tax all of it. The state revenue department's rules are the source to check.

U.S. Treasury interest, by contrast, is exempt from state income tax everywhere. When comparing a taxable muni with a Treasury, that difference can narrow or widen the gap.

05Who tends to hold them

Taxable munis tend to make arithmetic sense for investors who would not benefit from the exemption anyway: those in lower federal brackets, accounts that are already tax-deferred, such as an IRA or a 401(k), and institutions such as pension funds and foreign buyers who have no use for a U.S. tax exemption. For these holders, a taxable muni competes directly with corporate bonds of similar rating and maturity, and the attraction is the credit profile of a government borrower rather than a tax break.

For investors in higher brackets, the comparison runs the other way. The tax-equivalent yield calculator shows how a tax-exempt yield compares with a taxable one at a given rate, and the tax-free municipal bonds guide explains what the exemption does and does not cover.

Funds exist on this side of the market too. Some municipal bond ETFs and mutual funds hold only taxable munis, including outstanding BABs.

06Same promise, different tax line

For the city, the bond is still a bond: the same council vote or ballot measure, the same official statement on EMMA, the same obligation to repay. A taxable muni that pays for a new water main in one town and a tax-exempt muni that pays for one in the next town are, in the ground, identical pipes. The difference is only in who the issuer could sell to, and at what price.

Chickasha, Oklahoma, offers a reminder of how many routes a public project can take. Its Centennial Park playground rebuild combined city money, a federal Community Development Block Grant and online pledges from residents, as described on the Centennial Park project page. Larger projects add a fourth route, borrowing, and the tax status of that borrowing is one more decision in the finance office.

FAQ

What is a taxable municipal bond?

It is a bond issued by a state, city, county or other public body whose interest is subject to federal income tax. It carries the same kinds of security as other munis, either a general obligation pledge or a specific revenue stream, but falls outside the Section 103 exemption, either because federal rules require it or because the issuer chose a taxable structure.

Why would a city issue taxable bonds instead of tax-exempt ones?

Common reasons include projects with too much private use, pension obligation bonds that would otherwise be arbitrage bonds, and advance refundings, which lost their tax exemption after 2017. Federal subsidies such as Build America Bonds also made taxable borrowing cheaper for issuers in 2009 and 2010, and taxable bonds reach investors who gain nothing from an exemption.

What were Build America Bonds?

They were taxable municipal bonds created by the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009. The Treasury paid issuers a subsidy equal to 35 percent of the interest on most of them. Between April 2009 and the program's end on December 31, 2010, issuers sold more than $181 billion in 2,275 separate issues. Many remain outstanding.

Are taxable municipal bonds exempt from state tax?

Sometimes. Federal law does not decide this; each state does. Some states exempt interest on bonds issued within the state even when the bonds are federally taxable. Others tax all of it, and most tax taxable munis from other states. Checking the state revenue department's instructions for the year in question is the reliable way to know.

Who should consider taxable municipal bonds?

They tend to suit investors who would not benefit from a tax exemption: those in lower brackets, accounts that are already tax-deferred such as IRAs, and institutions or foreign investors with no use for a U.S. tax exemption. For these holders they compete with corporate bonds of similar rating. None of this is a recommendation of a specific bond.